Estimated read time: 11 minutes | Category: Urban Legends | Last updated: June 2025
The eBay Listing That Started a Legend
In September 2003, a man named Kevin Mannis listed a wine cabinet on eBay. The listing was unlike any other on the platform. It came with a warning.
The cabinet, Mannis wrote, had been purchased at an estate sale from the belongings of a 103-year-old Polish Jewish woman named Havela, a Holocaust survivor who had emigrated to the United States after the war. When Mannis had tried to return the cabinet to Havela’s family, they had refused to take it — trembling, one family member had told him in broken English that he must never open it, that it contained a dybbuk.
A dybbuk, in Jewish folklore, is a malicious spirit — the displaced soul of a dead person that attaches itself to a living host or an object. According to Mannis’s listing, the cabinet had been used by Havela to trap such a spirit. And every person who had come into contact with it since had experienced nightmares, illness, and a series of misfortunes that defied easy explanation.
The listing went viral. The box sold. Then it sold again. And again. Each successive owner reported experiences strikingly similar to those described by Mannis — the same nightmares, the same smell, the same sense of malevolent presence. The story spread across the internet, attracted serious media attention, and eventually inspired a 2012 Hollywood horror film called The Possession.
The Dybbuk Box has become the most famous haunted object in modern folklore. And the full story — when examined carefully — raises questions that are as interesting as the haunting itself.
What We Know For Certain
- [FACT] Kevin Mannis, a woodworker from Portland, Oregon, listed a wine cabinet on eBay in September 2003 with a detailed account of its allegedly paranormal history. The listing attracted enormous attention and spawned significant media coverage.
- [FACT] A dybbuk is a genuine concept in Jewish mystical tradition — a malevolent spirit, the soul of a dead person, believed in Kabbalistic tradition to be capable of attaching to living people or objects.
- [FACT] The cabinet passed through multiple documented owners after Mannis’s initial sale, including Missouri museum curator Jason Haxton, who acquired it after a series of other owners and wrote a book about his experiences.
- [FACT] The Possession, a 2012 horror film produced by Sam Raimi and starring Jeffrey Dean Morgan, was based on the Dybbuk Box story and was a significant commercial success, grossing over $80 million worldwide against a $14 million budget.
- [FACT] Kevin Mannis revealed in a 2021 interview with the Los Angeles Times that he had invented the story of the box’s history — including the Holocaust survivor Havela and the dybbuk warning — as a creative writing exercise.
- [FACT] The physical cabinet — a Hebrew wine cabinet used for Sabbath rituals — is a real object. Its current whereabouts and ownership are not publicly confirmed as of 2025.
- [FACT] No scientific evidence of paranormal activity associated with the cabinet has been documented by any independent researcher.
The Original Story — What Mannis Claimed
[FACT] Kevin Mannis’s original eBay listing described purchasing the wine cabinet at an estate sale. He said the family of the deceased — a 103-year-old Holocaust survivor — refused to take the cabinet back, telling him through tears that it contained a dybbuk bound inside by the old woman during her time in Nazi-occupied Poland.
[FACT] According to Mannis, from the moment he brought the cabinet home he experienced a series of disturbing events. His shop was vandalised. Lights burned out. Employees quit without explanation. A business partner reported a hag-like figure attacking him in his sleep. Mannis himself reported nightmares of a terrifying demonic figure and waking to find bruises on his body.
[FACT] Mannis gave the cabinet to his mother as a gift. Within minutes of receiving it she suffered a stroke — her first. She communicated by blinking, he said, that she hated the box. He took it back. He subsequently gave it to other family members, each of whom returned it quickly, each reporting nightmares and illness.
[FACT] The cabinet’s contents — listed in the eBay description — included two 1920s pennies, a lock of blond hair bound with cord, a lock of black and grey hair bound with cord, a small statue engraved with the Hebrew word “Shalom,” a small golden wine goblet, one dried rosebud, and a single candle holder with four octopus-shaped legs.
[ANALYSIS] These contents — a collection of personal objects, hair, religious items, and ritual materials — are consistent with objects associated with Kabbalistic practice and memorial traditions. Their presence in a wine cabinet used for Sabbath rituals is unusual but not impossible to explain through non-paranormal means.
The Subsequent Owners
Iosif Nietzke
[FACT] The first eBay buyer, a college student named Iosif Nietzke, reported that within days of receiving the cabinet his hair began falling out in clumps. He described a persistent smell of cat urine and jasmine that no one else in his house could smell. He relisted the cabinet on eBay within a week, describing his experiences in a follow-up listing.
The Second Buyer
[FACT] A second buyer — who has not been publicly identified — reported similar experiences and also relisted the cabinet quickly, again with accounts of nightmares and illness.
Jason Haxton
[FACT] Jason Haxton, director of a museum of osteopathic medicine in Missouri, purchased the cabinet in 2004 after reading about it online. He subsequently wrote a book — The Dibbuk Box — detailing his experiences with the object, which he described as including skin rashes, coughing blood, and recurring nightmares of a malevolent hag figure consistent with those described by Mannis and other owners.
[FACT] Haxton eventually had the cabinet sealed — according to his account, using rituals recommended by Rabbinical scholars — and donated it to Zak Bagans, the host of the paranormal investigation television programme Ghost Adventures. Bagans incorporated it into his Haunted Museum in Las Vegas.
Zak Bagans
[FACT] Zak Bagans acquired the Dybbuk Box and featured it in a 2019 documentary called Deadly Possessions. He described experiencing significant illness after opening the box on camera — illness he attributed to the box’s influence. The box remains in his Haunted Museum as one of its centrepiece exhibits.
The 2021 Revelation
[FACT] In October 2021, Kevin Mannis gave an interview to the Los Angeles Times in which he stated that the story of the Dybbuk Box — including the Holocaust survivor Havela, the family’s warning, and the original haunting history — was a work of creative fiction that he had written as a Halloween storytelling exercise.
[FACT] Mannis said the cabinet itself was real — a genuine Hebrew wine cabinet he had purchased at an estate sale — but that the narrative surrounding it was invented. He described himself as a writer who had been exploring the format of eBay listings as a creative medium and had not anticipated the story spreading as far as it did.
[FACT] Mannis’s revelation was met with mixed responses. Jason Haxton maintained that his own experiences with the cabinet were genuine regardless of the original story’s fictional status. Zak Bagans continued to feature the box in his museum. Many who had followed the story online expressed scepticism about Mannis’s claim that the story was fiction — arguing that his admission was itself part of the mythology.
[ANALYSIS] The 2021 revelation is one of the most important documented examples of how internet folklore is created and sustained. Mannis invented a story. It spread virally. Subsequent owners — primed by the story to expect paranormal experiences — reported experiences consistent with those expectations. A film was made. A museum exhibit was created. And when the original author admitted the story was fiction, the legend had become sufficiently self-sustaining that the admission changed almost nothing.
The Dybbuk in Jewish Tradition
Understanding the Dybbuk Box requires understanding the tradition it draws from — and how accurately it reflects that tradition.
[FACT] The dybbuk is a genuine concept in Jewish mysticism, particularly in the Kabbalistic tradition that developed in medieval Spain and later in Eastern Europe. A dybbuk (from the Hebrew word meaning “to cling”) is the soul of a dead person that has failed to pass on to the afterlife — typically because of unfinished business, unresolved sin, or violent death — and that attaches to a living person to complete its earthly purpose.
[FACT] Dybbuk possession — and the rabbinical rituals for expelling such spirits — are documented extensively in Jewish folk tradition and literature, particularly in Ashkenazi Jewish communities of Eastern Europe. S. Ansky’s 1920 play The Dybbuk is the most famous artistic treatment of the tradition and brought it to wide literary attention.
[FACT] The concept of binding a dybbuk into an object — as opposed to a person — is less established in mainstream Kabbalistic tradition. Most dybbuk accounts involve possession of human hosts rather than entrapment in physical objects. The wine cabinet as a vessel for a bound spirit is an innovation on the traditional concept rather than a direct reflection of it.
[ANALYSIS] This distinction matters because it suggests the Dybbuk Box narrative — even in its original form — was drawing on a real tradition in a creatively modified way rather than reporting an established folk practice. The dybbuk is real Jewish folklore. The dybbuk box is an internet-era elaboration of that folklore.
The Psychology of Haunted Objects
The Dybbuk Box raises important questions about how haunted object narratives work psychologically — questions that apply well beyond this specific case.
[FACT] Research in psychology has demonstrated that people who believe an object has a negative history associated with it tend to report negative experiences when interacting with it — even when the history is fabricated. This is a well-documented nocebo effect — the negative equivalent of placebo — in which expectation of harm produces genuine physical symptoms including nausea, headaches, and sleep disturbance.
[THEORY] The consistency of reported experiences across Dybbuk Box owners — the nightmares, the smell, the sense of presence — is entirely consistent with a nocebo effect operating on people who have read the eBay listing and its sequels before receiving the object. Each owner was primed to expect exactly the experiences they subsequently reported. This does not mean the experiences were not real — the distress was genuine. It means the cause was psychological rather than paranormal.
[THEORY] The recurring nightmare of a hag-like figure — reported by Mannis, the subsequent owners, and others — is consistent with a documented phenomenon called sleep paralysis, in which a person wakes unable to move and frequently reports a malevolent presence or figure sitting on their chest. Sleep paralysis is common, well-understood neurologically, and cross-culturally reported in ways that map onto local supernatural beliefs — demons in medieval Europe, the Old Hag in Newfoundland, the kanashibari in Japan. In the context of the Dybbuk Box, it maps onto the dybbuk tradition.
What Makes the Dybbuk Box Important
The Dybbuk Box matters beyond its status as a horror story for several reasons that are genuinely interesting.
[ANALYSIS] It is one of the most documented cases of internet folklore creation — a story whose origin can be precisely identified, whose spread can be tracked, and whose persistence after the author’s admission of invention can be studied in real time. Most urban legends develop over generations with uncertain origins. The Dybbuk Box developed over two decades with a documented creator who has admitted the fictional origin. Its persistence despite this admission is a remarkable demonstration of how legends achieve independence from their creators.
[ANALYSIS] It also demonstrates the power of objects as carriers of narrative. The cabinet itself is unremarkable — a Hebrew wine cabinet of modest age and no particular distinction. What makes it the Dybbuk Box is the story attached to it. Once that story had sufficient cultural traction, the object became the story — and the story became more durable than any debunking.
[FACT] The Dybbuk Box has been credited with renewing popular interest in Jewish mystical tradition and the concept of the dybbuk among audiences who would not otherwise have encountered it. Whatever its origins, it has functioned as an unintentional ambassador for a genuine and rich folkloric tradition.
Conclusion
Kevin Mannis invented a story about a wine cabinet. The story spread across the internet, accumulated additional reported experiences from subsequent owners, inspired a Hollywood film, and generated a museum exhibit. When Mannis admitted the story was fiction, the legend continued without him.
The Dybbuk Box is not a haunted object in any verifiable supernatural sense. It is a story that became an object — and then an object that became a story powerful enough to survive the truth about its origins.
Whether the experiences reported by subsequent owners were caused by a bound spirit, by the nocebo effect of a compelling narrative, by sleep paralysis given a cultural framework, or by something else — those experiences were real to the people who had them. The distress was genuine. The nightmares were frightening. The illness was felt.
What the Dybbuk Box actually contains, in the end, is not a dybbuk. It contains a question that is genuinely interesting: what is the difference between a haunted object and an object with a sufficiently powerful haunting story attached to it? And does that difference matter if the effects are the same?
Written and reviewed by the MysteryVerse editorial team. Facts sourced from Kevin Mannis’s original eBay listing (archived), his 2021 Los Angeles Times interview, Jason Haxton’s book The Dibbuk Box (2011), academic research on dybbuk tradition in Jewish folklore including Yoram Bilu’s ethnographic work, and verified media coverage from the Los Angeles Times, Vice, and Entertainment Weekly.
The dybbuk is a genuine concept in Jewish mystical tradition treated with respect throughout this article. The Dybbuk Box is an internet-era elaboration of that tradition whose fictional origin has been confirmed by its creator.
Spotted an error? Contact us and we will correct it promptly.